Earlier this evening, I finished the final book in Stephenie Meyer’s vampire saga. Breaking Dawn was not, in my estimation, as good as its predecessors. I felt the book had a variety of problems that boil down to one main issue. I expect books about the supernatural to stretch my credulity, but this book went over my credulity line.
Spoilers follow, so stop reading now if you intend to read the book and don’t want plot details revealed.
In this novel Bella, Meyer’s protagonist, marries her Edward (who was a little too bossy and controlling — and yes, he may be from a more patriarchal era, but I still don’t like it) and inexplicably gives birth to a half vampire/half human child. The birth would have killed her except Edward is able to heal Bella’s injuries by making her into a vampire. As a vampire, much of the quirks that make her personality accessible to teenage girls — her insecurity and clumsiness — fall away in the face of her superhuman powers. And she defies the mold by displaying amazing self control and powers, considering she is a newborn vampire. Meanwhile, Jacob inexplicably imprints on Edward and Bella’s daughter Renesmee. Never mind she’s not part of the Quileute tribe. See what I mean? Finally, another vampire glimpses Renesmee and thinks Carlisle’s coven has done the unthinkable — created a vampire out of a child. Supposedly it’s a crime to create child vampires because they have vampire strength and no control. The Volturi — the guardians of the vampires’ secret — descend upon Bella and her family, but she’s not about to give up without a fight.
I believe the best book in the series remains the first, although I liked parts of each of the others, even this one. However, Breaking Dawn was easy to put down for long periods of time, and it was difficult to pick up again sometimes. I had eventually read through too much of it to put it down. Once I invest in a book by a certain number of pages, I tend to plow through. Overall, I was disappointed with this book, but the series as a whole is a satisfying, fun read.
2 thoughts on “Breaking Dawn”
So, after reading that you consider Twilight the best, I have to ask: Will you see the movie?
Oh, yes. I do plan to see it, and I hope my daughter will come with me. She didn't read Breaking Dawn because she was unhappy with how Eclipse ended — she wanted Bella to pick Jacob. I didn't really care so much because it was so obvious that Stephenie Meyer herself wanted Bella to pick Edward that there never really was any other outcome.
Comments are closed.